Critical Analysis of Major Electoral Reforms in India

2024-11-19

Notable Quotes

"India is valued the world over for three things over all others: The Taj Mahal; Mahatma Gandhi; and India's electoral democracy."

  • Gopalkrishna Gandhi (2013)

"The heart of the Parliamentary system is free and fair elections periodically held, based on adult franchise, although social and economic democracy may demand much more."

  • Supreme Court of India (1978)

Core Challenges

The electoral process faces several key challenges:

  • Decriminalization of politics
  • Fake news proliferation
  • Financial influences
  • Proper adjudication
  • Adherence to democratic principles

Major Reform Areas

Anti-Defection Laws

  • Issues with wholesale vs retail defection
  • Constitutional Amendment implications
  • Speaker's powers and judicial review concerns

Election Commission of India

  • Role as fourth pillar of democracy
  • Financial independence issues
  • Decision-making structure
  • Resource allocation challenges

Financial Reforms

  • High electoral costs
  • Money power influence
  • Campaign financing issues
  • Need for expenditure control

One Nation One Election

  • NITI AAYOG proposal
  • Constitutional amendment requirements
  • Practical implementation challenges

Internal Party Democracy

  • Limited regulatory framework
  • Registration and accountability issues
  • Lack of deregistration provisions
  • Tax benefit oversight

Conclusion

Electoral reforms require comprehensive approach addressing structural, financial, and procedural aspects while maintaining democratic values and constitutional principles.