Critical Analysis of Major Electoral Reforms in India
2024-11-19
Notable Quotes
"India is valued the world over for three things over all others: The Taj Mahal; Mahatma Gandhi; and India's electoral democracy."
- Gopalkrishna Gandhi (2013)
"The heart of the Parliamentary system is free and fair elections periodically held, based on adult franchise, although social and economic democracy may demand much more."
- Supreme Court of India (1978)
Core Challenges
The electoral process faces several key challenges:
- Decriminalization of politics
- Fake news proliferation
- Financial influences
- Proper adjudication
- Adherence to democratic principles
Major Reform Areas
Anti-Defection Laws
- Issues with wholesale vs retail defection
- Constitutional Amendment implications
- Speaker's powers and judicial review concerns
Election Commission of India
- Role as fourth pillar of democracy
- Financial independence issues
- Decision-making structure
- Resource allocation challenges
Financial Reforms
- High electoral costs
- Money power influence
- Campaign financing issues
- Need for expenditure control
One Nation One Election
- NITI AAYOG proposal
- Constitutional amendment requirements
- Practical implementation challenges
Internal Party Democracy
- Limited regulatory framework
- Registration and accountability issues
- Lack of deregistration provisions
- Tax benefit oversight
Conclusion
Electoral reforms require comprehensive approach addressing structural, financial, and procedural aspects while maintaining democratic values and constitutional principles.